"Who would have thought that reading the Bible every day would hurt my faith?"My friend from work responded:
He has some great points. And to be honest, there were times when I imagined that at the end of this project, I would end up with no faith left at all and indeed, become an atheist, or at least agnostic. I imagined that this blog would turn into a book calledReading the bible made me an atheist... It shouldn't be about 'faith' which is a euphemism for believing in spite of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. I wish more 'believers' would be like you and take more than 5 minutes out of their lifetimes to actually ask the difficult questions about what they have been brought up to believe and have ... See More probably never analyzed it in an objective way. As the old saying goes: faith is believing what you know ain't so...the more you question, the more the true answers will reveal themselves....a thought that I live by: don't question the answers, question the questioner. The quickest route to enlightenment. Follow that path and you will understand the bible for what it really is....
"Faith Lost: How Reading the Bible Every Day Turned Me Into an Atheist"
Let me take his points one at a time.
1) When he said "Reading the Bible turned me into an Atheist" I was hit with a sense of dread that the same thing would happen to me. But then I thought,
"How could reading something which is designed to convince you - without a doubt - of the existence of God and the sacrifice of Jesus, convince you of the opposite?"Indeed there have been many times, just in these three and a half months, that I have been on the brink of giving up on my faith altogether - as a direct result of reading the Bible. Last night was one of those times. My conclusion was this:
"If I am reading something designed to give me faith in God, and it is having the opposite effect, I am obviously not understanding it properly"
2) "Faith is believing in what you know ain't so"
I disagree with this definition. My definition of faith is believing in something that you can't emphatically prove exists. We can have faith that a loved one will pull through a serious illness. We can have faith that our children will grow up to be wonderful people. And we can have faith that if we work hard enough, we will be rewarded for our efforts.
I'm sure everyone has gone through at least one of these scenarios. And you can't say that you know its false that your kid will grow up to be awesome. You know its a distinct possibility and your belief in that exists as a strong desire within you. However, you can't prove that it will actually happen but you have faith that it will.
In the same way, I can't prove God exists. I can't. No one can. But based on my personal experiences, the way the world is structured, and the way my life has come together, I have faith that he is truly there.
3) "The more you question, the more the true answers will reveal themselves"
I couldn't agree with this more, but I think we are seeing it from opposing ends. I think coming across these tough questions and problems with my faith have been extremely enlightening to the overall story of Christianity. When I reach a conclusion that puts opposing facts together to reveal a new, beautiful fact about God it gives me a new sense of hope and strength in my faith.
As many times as I have hit something that makes me want to give up, I have had just as many experiences that reignite my faith and send a new understanding soaring into my heart. And that is what gives me the faith that I am following the right path for my life.
I think these are definitely the right questions to focus on. There are a few more options on the table than Christian, Atheist, or Agnostic though. A lot of times in discussion, we will carry on as if these are the only options. I do this all the time unfortunately. Actually, there are many different possibilities. What if you changed your religion as a result of reading the bible and became a Buddhist? Maybe you become indifferent to religion and take an existentialist or humanistic approach. Anyway, I wanted to add my additional thoughts to your points above:
ReplyDeletePoint 1) If your conclusion is that when you encounter any cognitive dissonance while reading the bible it is because you don't understand something, then justification is inevitable. You will find some reason to explain it and move on. My problem with this is, what if you are understanding it correctly and the issue is actually morally bankrupt and/or illogical? You need to account for this possibility.
Point 3) Questioning your beliefs is really important. A lot of times I think there is more to learn from the questioning process than the conclusions we reach. I always find it very rewarding when I end up changing my mind on a particular issue though.